Monday, December 31, 2007

Poll Results

Poll #2
Question: How many no limit tournaments $300 and up do you plan to enter this year?

Choices: 0, 1-3, 4-7, 8 or more

Results: 1-3 (66%), 4-7 (33%) [3 votes]. Needless to say the results are disappointing with only three voters. Perhaps folks like to play in smaller buy-in tournaments.


Poll #1
Question: What do you do with top two on the flop on a dangerous board (straight and flush draws) with significant flop action and up against two other players when you have a very small investment in the pot?

Choices: Fold, All-In, Phone a Friend

Results: 40% fold, 40% phone a friend, and 20% all-in [10 votes]. The phone a friend results are a little disappointing, that was really for kicks, unless it means non-poker players are reading the blog, then I guess that's a good sign. It is intriguing that the majority chose fold, as I expected the winning choice to be all-in. In one of my blog entries (check it out here: Top Two On The Flop) I do in fact indicate folding as being the best choice, but that was in a specific situation based on a very good read. Based on the poll question, since top two is a powerful hand and the only better hand is a set, it makes equal sense to go all-in, pushing out those drawing hands and possibly getting heads-up with just one other player on a draw, or even taking down the pot right there. However, with only a small investment in the pot, if you are up against a set, some people may have thought, it makes sense to fold anyway and avoid trying to draw out to a full house, which would happen only 17% of the time. Tough question, tough choice.

Wednesday, December 19, 2007

Playing The Nuts and Ockham's Razor

You know I like to fantasize about poker hands. Actually, it helps me think about various situations that I have not specifically come across yet so when I do encounter them I can think lucidly about the situation when I am actually in it. In the following situation you are playing a $100-$200 NL cash game (I told you it was a fantasy). You can put yourself in the shoes of either player in this scenario and hopefully get something out of it.

You open raise from middle position to $700 after looking down at KK, folds around to bb who calls. $1,500 to the flop. Flop is AKK. Check-check to the turn, which brings a Q. Your opponent bets $1,000, you raise to $3,000, he calls. $7,500 to the river, which brings a blank, say a 5. Your opponent bets $8,000, you raise all-in (you have $16,300 total), your opponent calls. He flips over AA for AAAKK and of course you show the nuts and take the pot of $40,100.

Pre-flop action
Your opponent flat calls your raise with rockets. That works of course. He did this for a few reasons: i) He is disguising his hand, ii) He is already heads-up with you, so a re-raise here is not necessary, iii) A re-raise to say $2,500 and he risks you folding (sure, it's better to win a small pot than lose a big one of course) - he does not want you to fold, he wants to get maximum value out of his rockets, and iv) If he does raise to say $2,500, he "risks" you making a third raise, which at that point essentially commits his stack. Naturally he doesn't mind that at all, but seeing a flop allows him greater room to maneuver and may bring greater rewards than getting you off your hand pre-flop. If the small blind had called then it would make sense for the big blind to re-raise.

On the flop
It's difficult to argue against slow playing the stone cold nuts here. Certainly you're hoping for a juicy turn to stir your opponent to action.

On the turn
On the turn the board is now AKKQ. When your opponent comes out betting $1,000 into the $1,500 pot, he: i) Is trying to buy the pot right there [I would consider someone trying to buy the pot in this situation if they did not have at least an A or Q] since you checked behind him on the flop, ii) Has QQ, and would bet out since he wants to see if you have any of the hands that beat him such as KK, AA, AK or KQ, iii) Has a big ace, and thinks he could either win it there or may be in a chop situation [any two hands like AQ or worse (AJ, A-10, etc.) is a chop since the hand would be AAKKQ], or iv) Has AA. Why the bet then? Well, it's a value bet that may get your attention regardless of what you have. And if you do have a big hand, your opponent figures, like AK or QQ perhaps, then he may be able to induce a raise out of you figuring that he has disguised his hand pretty good up to this point. Also, if you don't at least call a bet on the turn with this board, your opponent thinks, then you may not call another bet on the river anyway.

So when you raise on the turn, your opponent ought to be putting you on AK, QQ or KK at that point. Why raise with the nuts when you know that only one card on the river is truly a scare card (the ace, which of course would be a sick quad over quad situation)? The same reason that your opponent bet out on the turn - you think to yourself if your opponent does have a big ace or AA then they would certainly at least call your raise, and if they didn't have much, they would fold and you wouldn't have got any more value out of them on the river anyway. From your opponent's perspective the chances you hold the following hands on the turn: a) AK -- (1/46 X 2/45) = 0.00097 or 0.097% or about 1 in 1,000; b) QQ -- (3/46 X 2/45) = 0.0029 or 0.29% or about 3 in 1,000; c) KK -- (2/46 X 1/45) = 0.00097 or about 1 in 1,000 [same as AK]. So it is three times more likely you have QQ than you do either AK or KK, and the only hand that your opponent cannot beat is KK.

As an aside, another option on the turn is to smooth call your opponent's bet. That would have made the pot $3,500 to the river. Say your opponent again bets out on the river to the tune of $4,000, you are raising big anyway. If you go all-in, at this point your opponent has some chance to get away from his aces full with $5,700 committed still sitting with $14,300 behind, "your money" left on the table (if your opponent is good enough to get away from aces full here). And if you raise to $12,000 for example, he can call and if he loses does have $6,300 left, which was again "your money" left on the table. Thus I believe the best thing to do on the turn is raise and you force an even bigger bet on the river which would commit your opponent, or you may induce a re-raise on the turn from your opponent right then and there.

On the river
Here is the thing about Ockham's razor, which paraphrased is generally accepted to translate to, "The simplest solution is the best, however implausible it may seem." On the river your opponent makes a slight overbet of the pot, perhaps trying to give the impression that he is buying the pot (assuming you don't have at least an ace), then you go all-in. At this level your opponent knows you don't have QQ (which would be afraid of KK, AA, AK or KQ), and thus you have either AK or KK. He is committed to calling another $8,300 (remember he has $12,000 in already) since he now is a 50% chance to win and as I demonstrated with the math, either hand is equally likely. Is that true? From the action and the math, either AK or KK are equally likely indeed. However, can the 14th century theorist help us out here? If you're your opponent, can you get away from AAAKK, knowing that the only hand that beats you is KKKK? It sure is possible if you think about it in this way: i) "The simplest solution is the best..." Would AK go all-in on the river knowing that AA beats them? (KK is not possible for your opponent to have if you do in fact have AK) Probably not in this spot. Would they (you) go all-in with AK for just a chop, if the opponent also has AK? Probably not. Thus they (you) must have KK. ii) "...however implausible it may seem." From a deduced math perspective (don't know the exact term, if there is one) the odds that you have either AK or KK are 1 in 1,000, your opponent thinks to himself, but the fact that you went over the top all-in on the river now makes that chance 100% (that you have either) and 0.5 not 0.001 for each hand - an increase of 500 times! It is 500 times more likely you do have KK now, consistent with point (i).

If you were your opponent, would you be able to fold AA in this spot?

This hand is an example of the nuts versus the second nuts. If you held KK would you play it this way for maximum value? If you held AA would you be able to get away from the hand on the river? If you were the player who held AA and you thought they were the nuts the whole time, should you have also checked on the turn? I hope this entry helps the reader to think about similar situations they may have been in and invite additional comments for this post.

Friday, December 14, 2007

Advanced Poker Theory: Monster Folds

This entry is designed as a brainstorming session to try and figure out what to do in a hypothetical situation. To set this up properly, let's say you're playing in a large NL tournament where the buy-in is at least $300. The assumption here is that in tournaments, players in general don't place chips into the pot on stone cold bluffs, they have a tendency to play a bit tighter than usual, and therefore typically have a made hand or monster draw or some juicy pot odds to keep them around. (The reader may immediately disagree with this statement, regardless, the scenario below stands.)

So here is the scenario: Blinds at 25-50 no antes, you have about 6000 chips and your opponent in question has about 4000 in chips. Folds around to a late position raiser (to 150), you look down at AK on the button and re-raise (to 500), player calls. 1075 in the pot. Flop comes out K-6-K with two diamonds. Player checks, you bet 600, player goes all-in, you call. Player flips over 6-6 which holds up (you need the case K or another A to win).

Was there anything else you could have done differently?

Your opponent check-raised you all-in. It is clear that your opponent is afraid of something, what is he afraid of? Why didn't he come out betting on the flop? Because he only became scared because of your bet. Your bet indicates to him that you have a K, likely with a big kicker like A or Q let's say, or you could even have a pocket pair like QQ for example. If your opponent correctly puts you on one of these types of hands (he could pretty much eliminate quad kings because who would come out betting with the stone cold nuts?, and he could probably eliminate K6 based on your pre-flop re-raise), his check-raise - and not just any check-raise, an all-in check-raise at that - is saying he wants to take down the pot right then and there and not get drawn out on. If you are holding a hand like AK or QQ, your opponent thinks to himself, then any A, K or Q on the turn or river beats him. He may not know exactly what you have, but he could certainly be afraid of any over-cards. Overcards to what? Overcards to pocket 6's! If another seven shows up on the turn or river, how does he know you don't have pocket 7's or K7 for example?

If your opponent is not afraid because he has a monster he would just slow-play and check-call (another way to play the 6-6 of course), or has a weak hand (he would fold to almost any reasonable bet) or maybe thinks you are just trying to buy the pot (and may call hoping to outplay you or check it down, etc.). Thus, does not the check-raise all-in play give you some pause?! Another piece of psychology is that your opponent may put you on a big ace, even AK, and confident you will call an all-in with that hand! So if you are thinking that the all-in play is unsophisticated, think again - it could that the player puts you on AK and knows you will call. However, if that's the case, why not milk you for all your chips slowly rather than risk you folding to the all-in check-raise? Because perhaps that's the only way your opponent believes they can get your chips, and they are comfortable taking the risk of you hitting what they know to be a four outter. If we look at the hands you can put your opponent on when he check-raises you all-in, they can be reasonably described as either: A flush draw (remember that?!), AA (an overpair), AK (same as you), KQ (any other weaker kicker than you), QQ (any underpair), AQ (representing any two non-paired cards), K6 (the nuts) or 66 (the second nuts). I mean, any poker player right off the bat without this minutiae level of detail knows there is pretty much only one hand that beats him and that is 66. So does your opponent have 66?

Let's break this down: We should reasonably eliminate the flush draw, AA, KQ, QQ and AQ types of hands (see statement in opening paragraph). (In addition, can we not eliminate these hands only unless you think your opponent is putting you on a steal, and thus he has essentially re-bluffed you in his mind. If in fact your opponent is putting you on a steal, then would they not just call to try and outplay you on a later street or hope to check it down? The all-in play here is just too reckless - especially for a flush draw early in the tournament when the player has enough chips - to believe your opponent is bluffing, unless they have something like KQ, and that is the only hand you can reasonably beat here is the point, since hands like AA or QQ should come out betting a value bet on the flop.) Thus your opponent either has AK (same as you), K6 (the nuts) or 66 (the second nuts). At this point can we not eliminate K6 as well? Would he likely call a big re-raise pre-flop with K6? Probably not. Anything is possible, but probably not in this case. And would he check-raise all-in with the nuts? So that's two strikes against that hand. (Although K6 can also get drawn out on by the same AK or KQ type of hands roughly 10% of the time with two cards to come.) So we're down to AK or 66. (At this point the astute reader will see that the best you can do is chop.) You're put to a decision early in a tournament for a good portion of your chips, but you also know that soon the blinds are going up to 50-100 and if you have 2000 chips you're still at 20 times the big blind and can still fight, so you're tempted to call since you could have the best hand and still won't be out of the tournament if you lose.

From a math perspective, which hand is more likely, AK or 66? Since you have AK and there are two kings on the flop, your opponent will be holding AK approximately (1/47 X 3/46 = 0.0014) or 0.14% of the time. Since there is one 6 on the flop, the chances your opponent is holding 66 is (3/47 X 2/46 = 0.0028) or 0.28%. So it is twice as likely (.28 > .14) your opponent has the 66! And you could understand why he would go-all-in too, he doesn't want to get drawn out on by a better boat, even if it is only 9:1. (And if he does have the K6, then you're dead to three outs instead of four anyway.) Since you've invested 1100 into the pot, you still have around 5000 chips, plenty for early play at 25-50 with the next level at 50-100. If your opponent has any of the other types of hands then what a hell of a play he made.

So lay it down when your opponent check-raises you all-in, assured you thought through the scenario, and live to fight another hand. Even though there pragmatically is only one hand that beats you, that one hand is vulnerable to any overcard that may come. It's a nice pot for early in the tournament for your opponent to take it with an all-in, let it go. Now that's one monster lay down.

Thursday, December 13, 2007

It's a Cooler: Aces Full vs.....Aces Full

Last night at a NL home game I was in a hand with one other player...definitely a cooler. In poker, the term "cooler" refers to a hand that is very difficult for one player to get away from, since that player quite reasonably believes they have the best hand, but where the other player is more sure or knows they have the best hand, maybe even the nuts. This is a hand that players can get busted on certainly, and at the very least lose a big portion of their stack. Some quick examples off the top of my head in my experience include:
  • Flush over flush on the flop, one player is pushing their baby flush
  • Any other flush over flush, especially on a board with straight draws and no pairs
  • Straight over straight, on a board with no flush and no pairs
  • Full house versus full house

In the hand last night, I made a standard raise in late position with AQ off, dealer calls, blinds fold. Flop comes out A-Q-8 rainbow. I check, button bets, I call. Turn is a blank, I check, button bets, I raise, button calls. River is an Ace, based on chip stacks and pot size, I go all-in, button calls. Button shows A-8 for AAA88 and I'm sitting with AAAQQ.

In this scenario, the button did suspect something or was still slow playing their two pair on the turn, since they only called my raise on the turn, I could easily have something like Q-Q for a set or even A-K in that spot. When the case ace fell on the river, there is only one hand that beats the button's hand: A-Q.

Math for this scenario:

a) Odds to get a flop with A-Q-8 given two known starting hands of A-Q and A-8: ((2/48 X 3/47 X 3/46) X 2) + ((3/48 X 2/47 X 3/46) X 2) + ((3/48 X 3/47 X 2/46) X 2) = 0.0003469 X 3 = 0.0010407 or 0.104% or about 1 in 1,000

b) Odds for the case ace to fall on the river = 1/44 = 0.0227 or 2.27%

c) Odds for this board = (a) X (b) = 0.00104 X 0.0227 = 0.0000236 or 0.00236% or about 2 in 100,000

Given the board at the river, what are the odds the button thinks I could have A-Q?

This is roughly 1/45 X 2/44 = 0.001 X 2 = 0.002 or 0.2% or 2 in 1,000. Definitely a cooler.

With this action, and with the chip stacks and pot size on the river, I could easily be pushing trip aces with K-Q kickers (holding AK), or queens full of aces (holding Q-Q), and of course, aces full of queens (holding A-Q). So, theoretically, button could easily believe they are good 2 of 3 times and have to call with their aces full of eights. Again, definitely a cooler.

Wednesday, December 12, 2007

Poker Players Alliance

If you're a poker player, especially in the NYC area, then you should show support for the PPA: Poker Player's Alliance

Closing in on one million supporters as of December 12, 2007, the PPA, lead by former New York State Senator Al D'Amato exists "to promote the game, ensure its integrity, and, most importantly, to protect poker players' rights." The PPA's tagline is "keep it legal", so passing laws to protect our right to play online as well as convene in live play is what you are showing support for.

If nothing else, the minimum contribution of $35.00 (you can show support for free too) gets you a really cool t-shirt AND a poker calculator. (When I joined for $20.00, I got a t-shirt only, but that level doesn't exist anymore.) Descriptions of the PPA's contribution levels are here: PPA Contribution Levels